- Previous thread: [gentoo-user] ebuild help: java main class?
- Next thread: [gentoo-user] Where is the vala overlay?
- Threads sorted by date: gentoo 200910
On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 13:25:08 +0000, Neil Bothwick
wrote:
> On Mon, 02 Nov 2009 13:58:03 +0100, Jesús Guerrero wrote:
>
>> @preserved-rebuild never worked for me, maybe it's just that it doesn't
>> like ~arch. I am just too lazy to work on how to fix a thing when
>> there's an alternative that always worked reliably, revdep-rebuild.
>
> If it didn't work on ~arch, how would it ever make it into arch?
>
I am not the one to answer that, all I can say is that the few times I've
tried it, it kept rebuilding the same packages again, and again, and again
ad infinitum, as said, I didn't even bother to find what the problem was,
because I have a working alternative. Sure it could be better, but that
hasn't been the case for me with @preserved-rebuild.
I've seen people reporting the same problems in the forums, so I am fairly
sure that's a common problem and not just exclusive to my installations.
> The trouble with revdep-rebuild is that you have to break your system
and
> then fix it. Most of the time this is trivial, but updates like
expat-2.0
> showed the usefulness of being able to recompile the packages before
they
> were broken.
I can't understand that. You CAN'T recompile your packages against the new
ABI's until the new ABI is in your system, and hence your system is already
broken. There's no preemptive measure against this. Both methods fix the
system *after* it's broken.
--
Jesús Guerrero
wrote:
> On Mon, 02 Nov 2009 13:58:03 +0100, Jesús Guerrero wrote:
>
>> @preserved-rebuild never worked for me, maybe it's just that it doesn't
>> like ~arch. I am just too lazy to work on how to fix a thing when
>> there's an alternative that always worked reliably, revdep-rebuild.
>
> If it didn't work on ~arch, how would it ever make it into arch?
>
I am not the one to answer that, all I can say is that the few times I've
tried it, it kept rebuilding the same packages again, and again, and again
ad infinitum, as said, I didn't even bother to find what the problem was,
because I have a working alternative. Sure it could be better, but that
hasn't been the case for me with @preserved-rebuild.
I've seen people reporting the same problems in the forums, so I am fairly
sure that's a common problem and not just exclusive to my installations.
> The trouble with revdep-rebuild is that you have to break your system
and
> then fix it. Most of the time this is trivial, but updates like
expat-2.0
> showed the usefulness of being able to recompile the packages before
they
> were broken.
I can't understand that. You CAN'T recompile your packages against the new
ABI's until the new ABI is in your system, and hence your system is already
broken. There's no preemptive measure against this. Both methods fix the
system *after* it's broken.
--
Jesús Guerrero
Conversations: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing.
- [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Dale on 2009-10-24T20:16:15+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Alan McKinnon on 2009-10-24T20:22:24+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Dale on 2009-10-24T20:37:10+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Alan McKinnon on 2009-10-24T21:26:26+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Dale on 2009-10-30T11:18:03+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Jesús Guerrero on 2009-10-30T16:23:29+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Dale on 2009-10-31T03:35:11+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Alan McKinnon on 2009-10-31T19:27:24+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Dale on 2009-10-31T21:31:07+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Jesús Guerrero on 2009-11-01T14:09:24+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Dale on 2009-11-01T17:21:44+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Jesús Guerrero on 2009-11-01T18:21:25+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Dale on 2009-11-01T21:56:32+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Dale on 2009-11-02T05:08:18+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Jesús Guerrero on 2009-11-02T11:58:37+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Neil Bothwick on 2009-11-02T12:25:29+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Dale on 2009-11-02T12:44:45+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Jesús Guerrero on 2009-11-02T12:59:30+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Alan McKinnon on 2009-11-02T13:13:57+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing. by Neil Bothwick on 2009-11-02T13:49:57+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] revdep-rebuild vs. @preserved-rebuild [was: Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing.] by Jesús Guerrero on 2009-11-02T14:01:49+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] revdep-rebuild vs. @preserved-rebuild by Graham Murray on 2009-11-02T14:40:46+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] revdep-rebuild vs. @preserved-rebuild [was: Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing.] by Alan McKinnon on 2009-11-02T14:41:53+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] revdep-rebuild vs. @preserved-rebuild [was: Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing.] by Alex Schuster on 2009-11-02T14:51:14+00:00
- [gentoo-user] Re: revdep-rebuild vs. @preserved-rebuild by Harry Putnam on 2009-11-02T15:32:58+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] revdep-rebuild vs. @preserved-rebuild [was: Kmplayer, video and audio not syncing.] by Jesús Guerrero on 2009-11-02T15:39:27+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] Re: revdep-rebuild vs. @preserved-rebuild by Alan McKinnon on 2009-11-02T16:53:08+00:00
- Re: [gentoo-user] revdep-rebuild vs. @preserved-rebuild by Neil Bothwick on 2009-11-02T22:13:48+00:00
Related Threads
- arch-general - testing - news - archlinux
- advapi32: Fix GetSecurityInfo with NULL descriptor - wine
- flexcoders - dispatchEvent import - flex
- Need help with NetBSD in Ontario - netbsd
- svn commit: r951922 - in /tomcat/trunk: java/org/apache/catalina/core/StandardHostValve.java webapps/docs/config/systemprops.xml - tomcat
- pkg-discuss - code review request for pkgmogrify changes (14052, 16022, 16024) - opensolaris
- Bug 23112 - New: flash player install crashes - wine
- Samba - hardlink unlink-before-save? - samba
- 3 models and search condition - cakephp
- samba with kerberos - samba
- hunspell segfaults - openbsd
- placiing content and application on a microsoft DFS solution - tomcat